Monday, July 1, 2019

Lessons in Hispanic virtue signaling with accents

The Daily Kos reports about Julián Castro:

    Julián Castro spells his name with the accent over the “a” in his name. ... That small punctuation mark in Castro’s name serves as a powerful example [read: virtue signal] of nonwhite visibility, particularly for Latinx people ... For the United States, those accents are historic, if only because they likely represent the first Spanish diacritical marks on the name of any serious Latino or non-Latino candidate in U.S. history. ... But for many of the more than 55 million Latinos in the United States, that accent means much more. It says, “es nuestro momento,” this is our moment and we will not be denied.

Castro has made the accent a prominent feature of his campaign logo.

In today's "woke" environment of identity politics, therefore, it's not enough just to be able to speak Spanish. Rather you need to have the correct diacriticals, too. This means that Beto O’Rourke probably should change his name to Betó O'Rourke, or, on the theory that two diacriticals are more "woke" than one, Betó O’Rourké. Cory Booker, on the other hand, appears to be shit out of luck with respect to his name, but perhaps he could go live in San José.

Julian Castro's proposal sounds great to his "woke" constituency and the liberal media, but is actually a non-sensical non-sequitur

2020 Democratic Presidential candidate Julián Castro propelled the issue of reparations for the descendants of slaves into the national debate in March when he asked “If, under the Constitution, we compensate people because we take their property, why wouldn’t you compensate people who actually were property?”

Castro seems to be referring to the power of eminent domain granted to the Federal government under the 5th Amendment, which reads:

    ... nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.

Castro's argument appeals to the "woke" constituency of the Democratic Party and to the liberal media, but is, of course, a complete non-sequitur. The only logical argument that can be made on the basis of the 5th Amendment is: “If, under the Constitution, we compensate people because we take their property, why wouldn’t we compensate the descendants of former slaveholders, whose property (slaves) was taken from them through the Emancipation Proclamation?” Unfortunately, actually being logically consistent generally means you end up sounding a lot less "woke."

The hideous modern art of politically correct, uncompromisingly doctrinaire grievance/identity politics

In the Democratic debate on Thursday night, Kamala Harris expressed support for forced busing as a means to end segregated schools. Harris' position exposed her utter lack of knowledge of late 20th century history. All of us who were adults back then (Harris was not) remember that forced busing was one of the most divisive and inflammatory issues of that era and that it was opposed by most Americans, regardless of their race. A Gallup poll from 1973 found that forced busing was supported by only 9 percent of blacks and 4 percent of whites. If Kamala Harris wants to run on a platform of supporting forced busing to end segregated schools, she knows nothing about recent history. The fact is: if Joe Biden opposed forced busing, he was right; it was a terrible policy.

Harris also insinuated on Thursday night that Joe Biden is a racist because he had a working relationship with segregationist senators. Harris said "I know you are not a racist, but ... [I]t was hurtful [Awww, poor Kamala!] to hear you talk about the reputations of two United States Senators who built their reputations and career on the segregation of race in this country." If Ms Harris had only recalled the history of South Africa in the 1990's, she would have realized that, if it was ok for Nelson Mandela to work together with the segregationist F. W. de Klerk to end apartheid in South Africa (for which Mandela and de Klerk were jointly awarded the Nobel Peace Prize), it was ok for Joe Biden to work together with segregationist senators to end segregation in America. After all, Biden's record on race was known to Barack Obama, the first black president, and must have been acceptable to him, since he selected Biden as his running mate two times in a row. [This is not to say that I support Joe Biden. I still can't believe the Dems will nominate "Sleepy Joe." I never would have imagined myself coming to his defense. I guess it's a generational thing.]

Finally, Harris joined all the other Democratic candidates on Thursday night in raising her hand in support of decriminalizing illegal immigration and providing health care for illegal immigrants. Once again, her support for these positions reveals an utter lack of familiarity with late 20th century history, this time the history of the Delano Grape Strike and Boycott and early Latino activism in her own home state of California in the 1960's and 1970's. Harris was obviously unaware of the fact that Cesar Chavez, today's icon of Latino activist groups and the Left, actually fought against illegal immigration because he knew that an endless flood of illegal Hispanic immigrants entering the country would undercut the wages and benefits of those Hispanics who were already here. As immigration expert Mark Krikorian writes of Chavez: "[H]is views on border control would be a perfect fit in the Trump administration."

Eric Swalwell (the dweeb in the class that everyone wishes would just shut up) proclaimed on Thursday night that "the torch needs to be passed to a new generation of Americans." My strongest impression from new-generation-candidate Harris is that she needs to bone up on late 20th century history before she can claim to have enough wisdom to lead this country. She seems not so much to have absorbed the great lessons of the history of her state, the nation, and the world -- a prerequisite for being a great stateswoman -- as she has mastered the hideous modern art of politically correct, uncompromisingly doctrinaire grievance/identity politics.

Tuesday, March 12, 2019

All revved up

I just got the Winter 2018/9 issue of the Claremont Review of Books. So, I'm all revved up this afternoon.

The lead article is "Conservatism After Trump" by senior editor William Voegeli. Here are some representative quotes [with the same example, namely, private health insurance vs. Medicare-for-All, inserted by way of illustration in each quote]:

    In How to Be a Conservative (2014), the English philosopher Roger Scruton says that conservatism originates in "the sentiment that good things [e.g. private health insurance] are easily destroyed, but not easily created [Medicare-for-All]."

    [We take current conditions for granted.] In doing so, we stop comparing our condition [private health insurance] favorably with known, existing alternatives and begin comparing it unfavorably with hypothetical possibilities [Medicare-for-All].

    [O]ne of the most basic conservative principles, as summarized by Thomas Sowell [is]: don't replace one thing that works [private health insurance] with a different thing that sounds good [Medicare-for-all].

This same basic thought was precisely what I was getting at recently when I wrote in my blog:

    Following Burke, I am guided by the following principle: as soon as a person starts talking about tearing the entire system (private health insurance) down and replacing it from the ground up (with Medicare-for-all), I know s/he is a charlatan. For, as Burke correctly observed, when you tear down the entire system, what you end up with is not a wonderful new system, but a wasteland. This is because you have destroyed the old system and then you discover that replacing it with a new system from the ground up is frighteningly more complex and expensive -- and oftentimes bloody -- than you ever could have imagined. The French and Russian Revolutions taught us this lesson. And it is with the horrors of the French and Russian Revolutions in mind, that we ought to reject the crazy, utopian, abstract, socialist theorizing of the Kamala Harrises and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortezes of the world.
Update:

The interesting thing is that the same principle frequently applies to software engineering.

That is, whenever someone starts talking to you about "refactoring" a body of code, your bullshit meter should start flashing red. Code almost always starts out with a nice, clean, architecturally and algorithmically sound design. Over the years, as the code is used in real life and is modified to handle real problems, it accumulates cruft to perform various kinds of special purpose processing. Inevitably, some young software engineer comes along, looks at the code, and says "This code is really ugly. It needs to be refactored." (This software engineer was often named Sabaziotatos.) Oftentimes, the young software engineer is influenced by the latest trends in "cool" new technology and wants to rewrite the old code base to use the cool new technology.

The young software engineer ends up replacing the old body of code, which has been in operation for a long time and works, with a new body of code that is very pleasant to look at, and works mostly, but fails to handle all the various special purpose processing problems (some of which the young software engineer was not even aware of) and has bugs of its own. This young engineer's work is performed at great expense to the company and at great inconvenience to the customers, who need to replace their old software with the new software and who are the ones, inevitably, who discover that their particular special purpose processing doesn't work any more or that the new software has the new bugs.

In other words, as Thomas Sowell warned: don't replace one thing that works with a different thing that sounds good.

Monday, March 11, 2019

Alex, András, Aristotle, and The Dead

The other night, I watched the documentary Free Solo. The film chronicles Alex Honnold's solo ropeless ascent of El Capitan in Yosemite (a first and so far unduplicated accomplishment), a performance that took 3 hours and 56 minutes.

Coincidentally, a friend of mine reminded me the other day that he is going to the Bach Fest in Leipzig in June. (I have attended the Fest in the past and highly recommend it.) At one of the concerts, Sir András Schiff will play all six Bach Partitas (BWV 825–830), a performance that will last approximately 2 hours and 40 minutes. (I saw Schiff perform the Bach piano concertos BWV 1054-5 last month in San Francisco and he was marvelous.)

I was struck by the similarity between Alex and András. During the several hours of his climb, Alex was required to execute a complex sequence of physical moves with precision and without error. When András plays the Partitas, he will be doing the same thing over a comparable period of time. In other words, the activities of both men are amazing feats of physical dexterity/endurance and unwavering mental concentration over a long period of time during which neither soloist is allowed to make even a single mistake. (On the obvious difference in the risk of the two activities, see below.)

In one sense, the name of the documentary, Free Solo, couldn't be more misleading. The adjective "Free" suggests that the activity is one of spontaneous improvisation, when, in reality, Alex spent years of roped practice on the face of El Cap getting down the moves he was going to need to execute on various difficult passages of his climb (at one point in the film, Alex rattles off a list of such moves). In just the same way, it is the years that András has spent practicing the various devilish passages of Bach that allow him to step out on the stage to give a performance.

Towards the end of the documentary, Alex makes some remarks about "performance" and the "warrior ethic:"

    For [my girlfriend] the point of life is like, happiness,. To be with people that make you feel fulfilled; to have a good time. For me, it’s all about performance. Anybody can be happy and cozy. […] Nobody achieves anything great because they are happy and cozy. It’s about being a warrior. It doesn’t matter about the cause, necessarily. This is your path and you will pursue it with excellence. You face your fear, because your goal demands it. That is the goddamned warrior spirit. I think the free-soloing mentality is pretty close to warrior culture; where you give something 100% focus, because your life depends on it.”

What Alex says about performance and pursuing your path with excellence, whatever that path may be, applies equally well to being a rock climber or a concert pianist. Neither activity produces any tangible good for the world. Imagine a son who says to his father: "Dad, what I want to spend the rest of my life doing is climbing rocks." Or "... playing the piano." Either way, the father could easily conclude that the son had not made a particularly wise career choice. But, it matters little. What matters is that the son has chosen a challenging activity that he will pursue with passion and excellence. Whether he makes a good living doing what he does is entirely secondary.

I've been reading Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics lately. Aristotle defines happiness as: the active engagement of the soul in conformance with excellence. I think you can describe Alex's and Andras' activities as: the active engagement of the soul and the body in conformance with excellence. And, in that, both are achieving true Aristotelian happiness.

Of course, the one enormous difference between András and Alex is that if András makes a mistake, he doesn't die. The one possibly disturbing thing in Free Solo is that it seems fairly certain that Alex will perish some day when he does, inevitably, make that one random mistake. On the other hand, as Alex points out in the movie: we all will die some day. The difference for Alex will be that he will die having lived his life the way he wanted to. In listening to Alex, I was reminded of the following passage from the end of James Joyce's short story The Dead:

    Better pass boldly into that other world, in the full glory of some passion, than fade and wither dismally with age.
Bravo Alex. Bravo András.

Wednesday, February 27, 2019

The low-wattage Democratic frosh Congresswomen

In today's hearings before the House Oversight Committee, Michael Cohen testified that Donald Trump was a racist. Republican Congressman Mark Meadows then introduced testimony from Lynne Patton, a black woman whom Trump appointed to HUD, to the effect that Trump was not a racist. When freshman Democratic Congresswoman Rashida Tlaib got her opportunity to question Mr Cohen, she read the following remarks:

    Just because someone [i.e., Donald Trump] has a person of color, a black person [i.e., Lynne Patton] working for them, does not mean they aren’t racist and [mumble, stumble] the fact that someone [i.e., Congressman Meadows] would actually use a prop, a black woman in this chamber, in this committee, is alone racist in itself.

In other words, even if a Republican President has a black woman working for him, he is a racist. And even if a Congressman, whose nieces and nephews, as it turns out, are people of color, invites a black woman to testify that the Republican President is not a racist, that Congressman is a racist, too. Of course, if the Republican President had not employed and the Republican Congressman had not invited the black woman to testify, they probably would still have been labeled racists. This is because, in the eyes of the new radical leftists of the Democratic Party, Republicans, qua Republicans, are, simply, racists. I guess everything Republicans do is evidence that they are racists!

And yet, one is forced to ask, as Congressman Meadows then did: Isn't calling Ms Patton a "prop" not itself racist? Calling any black woman a "prop" is the equivalent of calling her a "tool" and implies that she is an Uncle Tom incapable of thinking for herself. Isn't that racism of the most vile kind?

After Congressman Meadows had requested that Ms Tlaib's remarks be stricken from the record, Chairman Elijah Cummings, obviously perceiving the outrageousness of his fellow Democrat's accusation, offered Ms Tlaib the opportunity to "rephrase" her statement. The look of exasperation and stunned disbelief on Chairman Cummings' face (at the 1:55 mark in the video) when Ms Tlaib simply offered to reread her racist statement is priceless! "How can she be so dumb?" the Chairman is obviously thinking.

Ms Tlaib then proceeds to reread her statement verbatim, offers to submit it for the record, and then proceeds to deny that she called Congressman Meadows a racist when she so obviously had. Huh?

The upshot is that, instead of proving that Congressman Meadows and President Trump are racist, Ms Tlaib ended up distracting attention from Mr Cohen's testimony and focusing it all on her own racist statements, thereby proving only how clueless and racist she herself is. Congratulations, Rashida, you, Alexandria Ocasio Cortez, and Ilhan Omar continue to be the best proof the Republicans have of what dim young lightbulbs are populating the Democratic Party these days.

(One more piece of advice to these Democratic freshman Congresswomen: if you are going to read statements into the record of Congress, learn how to read without stumbling.)

Tuesday, February 26, 2019

Kamala is just as much an economic quack as AOC

Here is part of an exchange that Kamala Harris recently had with John King during an interview on CNN:

    King: Can we afford [the Green New Deal]?

    Harris: Of course we can afford it.

    King: Two and a half, three trillion dollars a year for Medicare for all, by some studies. Depending on which portions of the Green New Deal you choose to do first ... That’s money. You know what the Republicans are going to say, tax and spend liberals, pie in the sky ...

    Harris: One of the things that I admire and respect is, the measurement that is captured in three letters: ROI. What's the return on investment? People in the private sector understand this really well. It's not about a cost. It's about an investment. And then the question should be, is it worth the cost in terms of the investment potential? Are we going to get back more than we put in?

What flippancy and glibness! What utter bombast! With all her talk about ROI and the private sector, you would think Ms Harris was some kind of venture capitalist from Sand Hill Road instead of a two-bit district attorney. Kamala Harris knows as little about calculating ROI as I do, even on minor investments, let alone on an investment of the magnitude of the Green New Deal! And we are supposed to be putting the execution of this enormous financial undertaking into her hands as President?

Investopedia defines the formula for ROI as follows:

    ROI = (Current Value of Investment - Cost of Investment) / Cost of Investment

So, in spite of what Ms Harris says, ROI is partially a function of Cost of Investment. And it is agreed by all that the cost of implementing all the proposals in the Green New Deal will be staggeringly high. (The American Action Forum, which is run by Douglas Holtz-Eakin, who directed the non-partisan CBO from from 2003 to 2005, estimates the Green New Deal may tally between $51 trillion and $93 trillion over 10-years.)

Given that the cost will be staggeringly high, the benefits produced by the investment (the Current Value of Investment in the above formula) will likewise need to be staggeringly high in order for ROI to end up being positive. But that is what Ms Harris, in her glib 30 second sound bite, is implying (why else would she even bring ROI up?), in exactly the same way that other California Democrats assured us that California would reap enormous benefits from "investing" tens of billions of dollars (or is the "investment" projected to be hundreds of billions now?) into a high speed rail system. And these California Democrats made these bold-faced assurances for years, right up until the newly elected Democratic governor of California, Gavin Newsom, pulled the plug on the project because the ROI was not materializing while the Cost of Investment was spiraling ever higher.

The simple fact is that, while she pompously touts the ROI of the Green New Deal, Ms Harris is not even willing to provide the numbers we need to calculate ROI, namely, a.) Cost of Investment, that is, some gross estimate of how much it will cost to implement all the proposals in the Green New Deal and b.) Current Value of Investment, that is, some gross estimate in monetary terms of the value of the benefits that will result from the investment. In other words, her entire statement is merely empty rhetoric.

This does not mean that I do not think that climate change is a serious problem that needs to be addressed with a great deal of urgency. Rather, it just means that we need to employ hard-headed solutions in approaching this problem instead of the political fantasies of economic quacks.

It was with this same quackery that Ms Harris suggested in a townhall meeting recently that we do away with the entire private health insurance industry in the United States:

    It is inhumane to make people go through a system where they cannot literally receive the benefit of what medical science can offer because some insurance company has decided it doesn't meet their bottom line in terms of their profit motivation. That is inhumane ... Well, listen, the idea is that everyone gets access to medical care, and you don’t have to go through the process of going through an insurance company, having them give you approval, going through the paperwork, all of the delay that may require. Who of us has not had that situation where you’ve got to wait for approval, and the doctor says, well, I don’t know if your insurance company is going to cover this. Let’s eliminate all of that. Let’s move on.

So, according to Ms Harris, Medicare-for-all will automatically, without any kind of burdensome approval process, provide all people (including illegal immigrants?) with access to whatever health care treatment medical science can offer, no questions asked, without any delay. First of all, the claim that there will be no approval process in a single payor healthcare system is simply ludicrous. Just like with a private insurance company, your doctor will need to seek approval from the single payor for certain significant treatments. And, just like with a private insurance company, approval will be denied in some cases. If a single payor system did not have an approval process, we would be talking not about a financially solvent health care system, but about a patient-wish-fulfillment-machine. Just like private insurance companies, a single payor system must ration the scarce and expensive resources of medical care over a large population of patients (which will grow much larger if Medicare-for-all is passed) based on a variety of considerations, one of which most certainly is cost. Secondly, the idea that there will be no delay in providing treatment is also ludicrous. Ms Harris is obviously unaware of the delays that veterans have had to endure in receiving medical care under the government health care system run by the VA. Instead of providing an entirely new Medicare-for-all system (including Medicare-for-all-illegal-aliens?), how about if we fix the existing system for veterans?

One final comment. Following Burke, I am guided by the following principle: as soon as a person starts talking about tearing down the entire system (private health insurance) and replacing it from the ground up (with Medicare-for-all), I know s/he is a charlatan. For, as Burke correctly observed, when you tear down the entire system, what you end up with is not a wonderful new system, but a wasteland. This is because you have destroyed the old system and then you discover that replacing it with a new system from the ground up is frighteningly more complex and expensive -- and oftentimes bloody -- than you ever could have imagined. The French and Russian Revolutions taught us this lesson. And it is with the horrors of the French and Russian Revolutions in mind, that we ought to reject the crazy, utopian, abstract, socialist theorizing of the Kamala Harrises and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortezes of the world.